Has anyone on the list used Lexia PowerUp Literacy with adults or know of folks in their state who have?
One of our regional adult ed managers wrote me that she is "looking for CCR compliant instructional software to support reading comprehension and fluency leading to critical thinking." While I did caution against expecting too much from a software program, there should certainly be some programs out there that can support the regional effort. I'm definitely interested to hear more about the experience or recommendations from anyone using reading-focused software with adult learners.
Thanks!
Hillary Major
Comments
Thanks for sharing the Adult Learning Zone link, Leecy. OER Commons can be overwhelming, and I think this group really helps focus on adult-ed relevant lessons.
--Hillary
We used Lexia years ago before Rosetta Stone took it over. A coworker whose child uses it says it's had great upgrades.
Our version was primarily focused on decoding -- based on syllable structures as I'd learned in my Orton-Gillingham training. There were some exercises in comprehension but that was not the emphasis. I do *not* know if upgrades go that way.
I found it was quite effective for the students who really weren't fluent decoders. I did a quick Slosson on a couple of classes and there would always be 2-3 students who guessed at words flat out (so they didn't see them as things to be decoded at all) and a few more who were limited by not knowing what to do when words got bigger. I suspect this depends a whole lot on their K-12 education so it would scope out differently in different places.
For comprehension, we're using Reading Plus now for practice. It starts with a good assessment of its own, and then students get vocabulary lessons and reading passages to read, with comprehension questions. The program tells you what kinds of questions students miss, so you can know what skills to target. It doesn't "teach" the comprehension, though the questions are clear enough so that they get students thinking about things in new ways. There are questions about the purposes of a sentence and since it's multiple choice, students get thinking about those processes (to compare things? to support an idea? To contradict an argument?).
I've found the Reading Plus people amazingly good to work with and they're getting more popular w/ adult educators ... they will do pilots and training so you can figure out whether it's a good fit.
For teaching comprehension, when I did that, Joanne Carlisle has some great booklets with thoughtful exercises that break down comprehension into simpler thinking. I would make half a dozen more exercises from her example, based on student interest.
Hope other folks have more to say on this! I know there's a good free reading comprehension product out there, too... can't recall its name...
Oh -- and while Reading Plus isn't designed "for adults," students get lots and lots of passages to choose from and they cover a host of topics including things career related.
Thanks, SUsan. Sounds promising! Leecy
Thanks for sharing!
You mentioned free reading comprehension products; the manager who originally raised this question to me has used Read Theory, which pairs 8 short passages with a single MC question each as an adaptive pre-test and then takes an adaptive approach in showing somewhat longer passages paired with multiple questions. What I've seen looks similar to what you said about Reading Plus: "It doesn't 'teach' the comprehension, though the questions are clear enough so that they get students thinking about things in new ways." I noticed it even includes some questions about logical fallacies (although it doesn't teach or explain fallacies, the MC questions and answers include some context clues so that students aren't entirely dependent on knowing the terms).
--Hillary