A psychological aspect (internalizing problems) of literacy issues

Hello,

Much discussion in the Reading and Writing group focuses on improving our literacy instruction through addressing curricular, assessment, and instructional practices. Let's expand those parameters a bit and consider a psychological factor that some learners confront i.e., internalizing problems. We know in general that the challenges learners with learning disabilities (LD) confront in childhood and adolescence continue into adulthood.

In fact, psychological factors such as anxiety, depression, and emotional well-being are even more prevalent for adult learners with learning disabilities (LD) in post-secondary settings and adults with LD in general than the non-LD population. So, the point might be made that recognizing and addressing these pyschological factors are important to our instructional planning and, more importantly, our learners' successful outcomes. Another point to state that may be obvious is that learners who internalize problems also have diminished capacity for information processing, metacognition, and working memory. So likely, their stress levels also increase as they work on literacy tasks for which they have a history of limited success.

So, what to do? Recommendations from a research article in the Journal of Learning Disabilities include improving executive functioning such as helping the learner develop the organization strategies that help them become more efficient with their time usage and effort. Being more efficient, better organized can reduce one's stress level because we have a coping mechanism.

Along a different track, if we are sensitive to learners' tendency to internalize their problems, targeted instructor feedback can help learners understand their challenges and indicate the progress that their (the learners') efforts are having for improvement. I think that we should focus on helping learners' develop a greater sense of their own capacity at problem solving, decision-making and improvement. Stress management strategies would be an important component.

Another avenue or approach is to help the learner compartmentalize his challenges so that s/he can identify the dimensions of life in which s/he is (relatively) successful (e.g., social relationships, family connections, employment, community involvement, hobbies, and other academic achievement areas). This self-awareness can help with the compartmentalizing of their areas of difficulty. We probably all understand some sense of our strengths and weaknesses and how they influence our choices and day to day activities. Helping our learners develop that understanding could be an important component of more successful learning, persistence, and achievement.

  • Your thoughts? 
  • How useful is this concept of "internalizing problems" for characterizing your learners?
  • Do you see it manifested often?
  • How do you address it successfully? 

Knowing that some (or more of you) love research, the research article that was the basis for my post is: 
Klassen, R.M, Tze, V.M.C., and Hannok, W. (2011). Internalizing problems of adults with learning disabilities: a meta-analysis. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 46 (4) 317-327.

Also, I'm just curious if you "like" this approach to developing Discussion topics.

Kind regards,
Daryl
Reading and writing group coordinator

Comments

Hi,

So I'm a bit puzzled about how to best address learners who recognize that they need help, are willing to regularly attend the adult education/literacy program, and yet continue to confront the challenges of anxiety, depression, and, or emotional variability. 

One approach might argue that those emotional issues will take care of themselves if we are successful with our instruction and I can agree to a point. On the other hand, those emotional issues might be the limiting factor for their learning. 

What do you offer those learners that's the added component and builds on the strong instructional practices? Do you change the frequency and how you provide feedback? Do you specifically have an intervention for them regarding their emotional well-being?

Given the prevalence of these issues in the population seems like we want to be very direct and intentional with our approach.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

Regards,
Daryl
Reading and writing COP moderator

Hi Daryl and All: You are so correct teaching, especially for our students who are anxious ,depressed or just plain over whelmed with going back into the classroom, is much more than content delivery. In the seven session Guest Discussion that I did in February of this year  entitled 'Teaching Strategies: Easing the Pathway for All Adult Learners to Develop Competence in the Classroom and Beyond" I dealt with strateiges to assist students who fall into the categories of function that you mention.

                          A quick and dirty [and most successful way] to meditate for anxiety and depression in the classroom is to always preprocess learning activities that will take place each day. As we all are aware, knowing what to expect relieves our anxiety. For students who seem unengaged, are slow processors and lack energy [depressed?] chunking information, never more that three related concepts at a time [an executive functioning principle], helps to make the work seem manageable and worht the effort of engagement.

                        There are more strategies  in Day One of the Discussion  [2/13/14]  Sessions 3 and 4 and in  Day Two of the Discussion  [2/14/14] Sessions 1 and 2. Lauri DiGalbo M.Ed ,CRC, LPC