Welcome to Part 3 of our Discussion: Integrating Health Literacy into Basic Skills Instruction

Hi Everyone!

This discussion series started in October, 2013. There are 4 parts to the series, and they continue to grow even after the advertised dates. We have laid down the basics of each topic, and here's what I hope will happen now: You will explore the ideas, resources and examples that we have talked about and then weigh in with your comments, questions and ideas. It doesn't matter if it's months or years after the discussion began. I hope that this discussion series will keep growing and evolving into something that will continue to be more useful as time goes by!

Please read and add to whichever part you like:

******************************************************************

This is the beginning of Part 3:

******************************************************************

Hi Everyone,

Thanks so much for bearing with us throughout this 4-part discussion series!

Please keep checking and commenting on last week's discussion, Resources for Addressing Health Literacy in ABE Programs. We will be adding more resources as we go along, and hope that you all will add some as well!

Also, feel free to keep commenting on the themes that came up in the first part, Introduction to Health Literacy in ABE and ESOL.

This week (and I know it's a short one!), we are talking about Integrating Health Literacy into Basic Skills Instruction.

I'm going to start with a definition of healthliteracy from the Calgary Charter on Health Literacy:

  • Health literacy allows the public and personnel working in all health-related contexts to find, understand, evaluate, communicate, and use information.
  • Health literacy is the use of a wide range of skills that improve the ability of people to act on information in order to live healthier lives
  • These skills include reading, writing, listening, speaking, numeracy, and critical analysis, as well as communication and interaction skills

I have put some of the words in bold: those that are the key skills. Look at the ones in the last part. what do you notice about these skills in the context of what you do as ABE/ESOL teachers?

Comments

Yes! You are already teaching all of those skills! So addressing health literacy simply means that you use health as a context area for teaching those same skills. This is why it should not take away from the comptetencies you are required to teach, but rather enhance them.

So you are teaching the same skills that are needed to improve both health literacy and literacy, and you are also teaching in a way that is particularly condusive to improving health literacy.

Let's look at some of the best practices that we use in teaching:

  • Use students' life experience as part of the learning process
  • Validate each person's knowledge and beliefs
  • Incorporate new knowledge and skills into real life
  • Practice these skills to make them meaningful
  • Process and reflect on the new knowledge and skills
  • Encourage students to teach others as a way to embed their knowledge and skills
  • Use the creative process
  • Use authentic materials

Any thoughts about this list? Do these make sense? Any more to add? 

How can these teaching practices be used to address health literacy? Please reply with your comments!

So let’s look at how we can use the best practices to integrate health literacy skills into our classes. The goal is to use our existing curriculum plan and our existing goals, but to infuse some health literacy into those. We do not want to take time away from those goals, but rather to use health as a context area for the skills we are teaching anyway. Often this can engage students and enhance to learning because it is so relevant to their everyday lives.

 

Throughout this section, I will refer to some excerpts from resource guides or curricula. The excerpts are all short, so I hope that you will read them as part of this overall discussion.

 

Here is an outline of how you might proceed.  These are the beginning steps. Later we will look at how to approach a specific teaching activity.

 

Please feel free to comment on any of the steps here! I would love to make this richer over time by hearing from you.

 

1.    Get your mindset ready for addressing health: It can feel threatening to be addressing health when your role is to teach literacy and language. The best way to frame it to yourself is that you are still playing the same role as always.

a.    Read this section from Family Health and Literacy: You Don’t Have to be a Health Expert.

2.    Introduce health in an open, non-threatening way: Health can be an emotional topic for many students. When you start out, it is good to approach health from a positive point of view. Frame it as good health rather than sickness.

a.    Read the paragraph: Introducing Health in the Classroom

b.    Look at this introductory lesson: Good Health. Please note that this lesson is the first in a full curriculum called HEAL:BCC. All the internal links in this lesson work EXCEPT for those to the Passport to Health. Use this link instead: http://healthliteracy.worlded.org/heal/passport/.

3.    Choose a topic together: To make this most relevant to your learners, it is always best to decide together what they want to study. The process you use to decide can flow from the lesson I mentioned in #2 above. You can do this orally: brainstorm and discuss as a large group or in smaller groups or partners. Or you can use some writing prompts to get people’s ideas: they can make lists or write a short piece about what they would like to study. They may choose a health topic like nutrition or colds & flu. Or they may choose access skills like talking to the doctor or finding their way around the health clinic.

4.    Talk, discuss and share knowledge, customs and beliefs: Health is an area where people from different families and different cultures will have their own beliefs, habits and traditions. These are all important to address and validate as you move forward in this process.

a.    Read this paragraph: How to Engage Students

 

These first steps should help to get you started and feeling ready to infuse health into your classroom plan. The next step is to choose teaching materials to use. Please share your thoughts!

In #2. b (above) there is a link to a good introductory activity as you start to address health.

See this other variation from the Charlottesville Adult Learning Center's EL-Civics Health Curriculum

Unit One: Exploring a Holistic View of Healthy Living

This includes specific suggestions for adapting the activity to different skill levels.

We've talked about how to get started and introduce the topic of health to our learners. Now let's talk about the next steps: using the available resources to teach health literacy skills while teaching literacy and language skills.

There are many choices of activities and lessons to use. You need to think about how much time you want to devote to this, what kinds of activities you want to use, and what language and literacy skills you want to work on.

You can also choose to follow a comprehensive curriculum or piece lessons together as you go. And the type of activity can range from tackling a story or reading to having a guest speaker in your classroom. Whatever it is, you want to prepare students, do the activity, then process it. Here’s a basic outline:

1.    Explore the chosen topic through a reading, an experience or an activity.

2.    Talk, discuss and share knowledge, customs and beliefs. (See #4 from the  last post.)

3.    Follow up with the kinds of literacy activities that you would do anyway. They will relate to the topic, but focus on specific skills, such as pronunciation, grammar or reflective writing. Many of the curricula or classroom activities you may be using will have these as options, but you may need or prefer to make your own practice exercises.

4.    Process the information and practice the skills with longer-term classwork. This could be a longer writing project, an oral presentation to the class, an interview with a family member, or a creative project.

5.    Revisit this activity or unit at later points in the year to continue processing.

 

 

Let’s look at an example of integrating health literacy into an ESOL or a beginning ABE class. Say the students decided to learn about taking medicines. We’ll use this resource for the example:

 

Staying Healthy: An English Language Learners Guide to Health Care and Healthy Living

http://www.floridaliteracy.org/FLCHLP/files/TE%20Files/CompleteTEBook.pdf

 

Scroll down to Chapter 3: Medicines

> > page 39 of the Teacher’s Guide (page 48 of the PDF)

 

Take a look at this chapter and see the kinds of activities it includes. I will note a few things that relate to some of the best practices we mentioned.

 

First, see the CASAS competencies that are addressed in this lesson. These are listed at the beginning of each chapter to show how these activities can align with the CASAS requirements.

 

Things to notice:

  • The guide takes you through the process of starting with a picture and giving prompts to discuss it. (This is like a code from Freire’s work.) This allows everyone to have a say and share their experience, beliefs and knowledge about the topic.
  • The key vocabulary that will be part of this topic is highlighted, and can be reviewed in the picture glossary in the back of the book.
  • The activities include a variety of ways to practice the new information while addressing grammar, pronunciation and math skills.
  • Authentic materials (pill bottles) are used.
  • There is a review of the material at the end with a short quiz.
  • There are suggestions for how the students can share this new information with others in order to reinforce their learning.

 

 

Activities:

  • Tap the stress: pronunciation
  • Grammar exercise: “How much?” vs. “How many?”
  • Hands-on activity: looking at medicine bottles
  • Math activities: measuring, equivalencies
  • Internet activities: suggestions for online exploration of medicines
  • Dialog: to practice speaking AND to empower learners to speak up!

 

So please explore this a bit and then share your thoughts or questions with us!

 

How would this fit with what you already do in your class setting?

How do you think your students would react?How much or how little does this feel

Now let's look at an example of a unit on filling out a health history form. This is a skill that everyone who sees a doctor needs to have, and using it as a class activity is very meaningful. Students are likely to be motivated, since they are likely to have been frustrated by this in the past. This is also an area where we as teachers can assure them that we, too, get confused by these forms!

This comes from the Queens Library Health Literacy curriculum for ESOL Learners.

From the Main Page, look at Lesson #7: Filling Out a Health History.

There are five activities in this unit:

  • Doing telephone role plays of making an appointment
  • Reviewing medical vocabulary that you might find on a health history form
  • Filling out a health history form (with support!)
  • Listening exercise with recorded health histories
  • Question and answer activity with partner

This unit is designed for ESOL classes, so there is a lot of speaking and listening practice. The Main Page has audio files for the listening activites. There is also an activity about the vocabulary itself, since this is a such a big challenge with health history forms. There is a sheet where students can write in the translations from their own language or a definition in their own words.

This does not have specific grammar or math activities, but can there are ways that those could be built around this.

Any thoughts on this?

Thanks for this great Wednesday question topic, and for these great lesson examples, especially the health history form lesson. 

This lesson example brings to mind a suggestion for another Wednesday question topic.  I know there is a load of information out there on creating forms—for which I’m grateful.  One of the most useful resources for me in tackling this issue has been ESOL and ABE teachers.  So my suggestion for a future Wednesday question would be, what can teachers of classes like the example you gave, tell us about what their students find difficult?  What are the barriers in forms?  What’s useful in addressing those barriers?  How are students processing the information on the forms?  I’d love to hear teachers weigh in on the details like, “what works best, a check box for yes/no or a line in front of yes/no, or a request to circle a yes or no?” A class like Health History lesson from the Queens Library where you can learn vocabulary, and become familiar with the use and purpose of this form is such a great solution—but in lieu of a class, what can ESOL and ABE teachers tell us about how to make the form itself less of a barrier?  

One of the difficulties with forms is that they “serve two masters.”  That is, they need to be useful to and fit into the system (clinic, hospital, etc) requiring patients to fill them out, (both in terms of information needs and recording and retrieving data) which drives the design and the questions asked in one direction. And, they need to be meaningful and understandable to the patients, which can lead to a whole different design direction entirely.  The data driven form doesn’t necessarily fill the client’s need to give information, nor are the questions contextualized in a way that allows the client to know why the information is being asked for. My thought is that ESOL/ABE teachers would have some great suggestions about how to negotiate this difficulty.

 

Thanks,

 

Kath Anderson

Thanks, Kath!

This is a great question, and like you said, one that I would love to explore more fully!  Adult learners represent the hardest-to-reach end-users of health information, so they are a great target audience to use for testing new materials like forms and patient education. These students can tell you better than most people what works and what doesn't.

There is a pretty strong consensus that universal design is the best approach to health education. This means that, for the most part, if materials are suitable for adults with low literacy skills, they will be better for everyone. But how do those who develop these materials find adults with low literacy skills to use for their pilot testing and focus groups? As you say, ABE classes are a great source for this. Plus, they are already coming to scheduled sessions with a trusted peer group, and have a teacher to guide them.

ABE teachers also can be excellent resources to help health folks learn how to present information clearly to diverse groups of people with different learning needs. This is what they are trained to do and have experience in doing!

So, teachers out there, please tell us what you think!! Has anyone done this? What kind of experience would a project like this be for you and your students?

Kath, how did you go about getting this kind of feedback from ESOL and ABE teachers?

Hi Julie,

 

In answer to the question, how do I go about getting feedback from ABE/ESOL teachers—mostly I just ask.

 

Specifically, I ask teachers to look at drafts of materials we’re working on and offer feedback.   This has proven to be really valuable.  Sometimes it’s people I know-- one of the board members on the non-profit health literacy organization that I work with is an expert ESL teacher and a former medical interpreter—he is an excellent resource, and I have occasionally been able to work with some of his classes as well as with him. But I have also reached out to people in my area on the Adult English Language Learners listserv.

 

I completely agree with you:  “ABE teachers also can be excellent resources to help health folks learn how to present information clearly to diverse groups of people with different learning needs. This is what they are trained to do and have experience in doing!”  And I look forward to learning from the community.

 

Thanks for your response—I so appreciate this listserv!

 

Kath Anderson

In Part 1 of this discussion series, we talked about what kinds of skills adult learners need in order to take care of their health. One skill that came up was digital literacy skills. David Rosen wrote: "Important digital literacy skills I think we need to teach ELLs include how to find these web sites, how to navigate in them, and how to know if or why the information they provide is accurate."

So this next example addresses those skills.

Who Can You Trust? Health Information and the Internet: Curriculum Sourcebook

The curriculum was developed by ABE teachers and librarians, and designed to use with middle school students and young adults in a non-formal educational setting. It has also been used with 5th and 6th graders, and would be appropriate or adaptable to use with ABE students.

It includes three 1-hour lessons:

  1. Using the Internet to Find Health Information
  2. Evaluating Health Information You Find on the Internet
  3. Demonstrating Health Information Literacy Skills

The activities include

  • Doing a structured “Treasure Hunt” for health information online
  • Using a “Quality Information Checklist” to assess the viability of the websites
  • Comparing Google searches with searching on recommended health websites
  • Researching online: practicing finding answers to specific health questions on the internet
  • Processing their experiences and self-assessment
  • Doing a community outreach project (e.g. create an educational poster, tutor seniors at a local library, etc.)
  • Writing a story-based self-evaluation

As you can see, this includes many components of literacy and language skills such as speaking, listening, reading writing and critical thinking. It also includes hands-on digital literacy skills, interacting simultaneously with checklists, screens and printed materials, and learning by doing.

This also serves a good model for the process of developing a curriculum like this. There was a needs-assessment, a pilot and an evaluation, all of which are described at the end of the sourcebook. There’s also an article about the process: Health Information Literacy Outreach: Improving Health Literacy and Access to Reliable Health Information Online in Rural Oxford County Maine.

Any comments on this?

Julie and others,

I think these lessons are a good introduction to some of the issues in finding and judging health literacy information. I wonder, however, what students do later, how they actually use MedLine Plus or other online health literacy information resources.

I wonder if there is a good qualitative study of adult learners who have been introduced to how to search for and evaluate online health information that describes what learners actually do afterwards: what health-related issues, problems or decisions they face, and how they deal with them.

The recent PIAAC international study of adult learners looked at health literacy. It also looked at Problem Solving in Technology Rich Environments. I wonder if the PIAAC results have any insights to offer on how adult learners search for, evaluate, and use health information they find online. Anyone here know?

I believe the PIAAC assessments will be available for adult literacy programs and individuals to take in early 2014. I wonder if these are relevant to health literacy and, if so, if anyone is planning a health literacy - related study using these assessments. Anyone know?


David J. Rosen

djrosen123@gmail.com


 

Hi David,

That's a good question. I don't know of any further study plans but it would be a very good idea! I'll put my feelers out to see if I can find anything out.

As for your PIAAC questions, here's what I can tell you: This study did not actually look at health literacy. It looked at literacy, numeracy and --as you say--problem solving in technology rich environments. However, it also asked a series of background questions about perceived health, how people get their health information, if they are insured, and if they have gotten certain health screenings. So there will be ways to compare the tested variables (such as literacy) to their health status and use of primary care services. 

I, too, would love to hear about anyone who plans to use this data for further health literacy study!

I started a new discussion about PIAAC, with a link to a webinar: Results of the PIACC (Program for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies) and Its Impact on the Health Care Community

David and others,

Who Can You Trust? Health Information and the Internet is a curriculum that introduces how to search for and evaluate online health information and was developed and piloted in rural Maine by teachers and librarians working with middle and high school studuents and young adults in non-formal adult education settings.  The curriculum sourcebook includes 3 one-hour lessons. The sourcebook also includes a description of the evaluation and result (see page 30, http://www.rvhcc.org/pdf/HIL_Sourcebook.pdf).  It's hard to collect the kind of follow up data you refer to but the Student Self-Assessment and Story-based Evaluation tools in Lesson 3 are useful for that purpose. 

You can find the published article at: Kurtz-Rossi, S., & Duguay, P. (2010). Health Information Literacy Outreach: Improving Health Literacy and Access to Reliable Health Information in Rural Oxford County Maine. JCHI 14:325-340.

Sabrina

---------------------------- 

Sabrina Kurtz-Rossi, M.Ed., Health Liteacy Consultant

SAVE THE DATE: Health Literacy Educational Leadership Institute, Tufts Universtiy School of Medicine, June 9 - 13, 2014, http://healthliteracyleadership.com